Posted by
Ganymede
A version of this post originally appeared in two parts at http://deconstruction-site.blogspot.com.
Ganymede here, a newly-acquired apprentice Lasher, and very excited to be on board. I'm a kinky, andro-romantic, trans-masculine asexual who's thrilled to become part of such an awesome queer feminist collective...
That's a lot of labels for such a small sentence, isn't it? And if you've hung around this blog for a while, you'll have noticed that we're
rather keen on matters of labelling and self-identity. In this post, I'm going to give my take on why they're so important: the problems they can cause when they don't work, and why, when they do work, they're so liberating.
Consider this interesting situation: as the notion of
asexuality is gaining ground, so too is the need to find a word for people who
aren't asexual. This is a controversial subject, where all of the possible candidates have unfortunate connotations (which is, of course, almost unavoidable when coining or
using labels). But, whatever word we settle on, we still find ourselves with a fascinating problem: when faced with the
concept that asexual people exist and therefore by process of elimination they
belong to the group described as "sexual", or "consexual", or "allosexual", some people suddenly realise that
they're not comfortable with the way their group - the
majority group - is portrayed in the media.
Usually
this only happens with minority groups; one parallel is gay men in
earlier decades potentially feeling dissuaded from coming out because of
media-based assumptions that
all gay men are ridiculously
effeminate. But... you
can't not come out as experiencing sexual attraction, because the default assumption is that everyone experiences sexual attraction. And the default portrayal of, well,
everyone in the media is that they're really rather obsessed with sex. And if you don't define as asexual, explicitly rejecting this portrayal, does that mean you're implicitly
accepting it?
That's one reason why I'm incredibly excited to see asexuality being discussed in the mainstream media. Those who
wouldn't self-define as asexual will be prompted to think more deeply about their orientation, and perhaps start to question the way sex
is dealt with in the media, and perhaps feel less ashamed to speak out
as "different" the next time they're stuck in a game of nervous,
exaggerated, face-saving sexual one-upmanship with friends who worry
that not thinking about sex every seven seconds will make them look
"gay".
But for every label, there will be lots of people who feel discomfort with using it, because of the people they're then implicitly associated with. Some
deal with this problem by calling themselves something new (like "equalist" instead of "feminist"),
which doesn't have the baggage of the past, but will never have the
weight of history. Some react by declaring themselves to be "real" or "proper" [insert label here]s, not like those
other [insert label here]s who shouldn't be allowed to use the word;
that never ends well. Another way of dealing with it is to sub-categorise yourself: if you're not sure you're asexual but you don't want to associate yourself with sex-obsessed media portrayals, you can co-opt a term like
demisexual or
grey-asexual to
help you narrow down your potential network of peers even further. Or,
just don't label yourself at all... which works fine, until you find
yourself labelled by implication ("if you aren't asexual, you must be
sexual/allosexual/consexual").
Fact #1: people will always try to label you.
Fact #2: whatever label you end up with, you'll always be sharing it
with a certain proportion of dickheads. In my opinion, the best thing
you can do is choose your labels with care, and then BE AWESOME so
loudly that you drown out the dickheads.
For every "label" you can think of, there are a
million people using it who come in a million different shapes and
sizes. Our society is starting to recognise inter-group variation to a
much greater extent than only a few years previously (adding and
accepting new labels like "asexual", "heteroromantic", "genderqueer",
"neurotypical"), and this is frickin' awesome, but it's just the
beginning. The much-needed next step is to come to recognise in
tra-group variation: whatever labels we take, we flavour them with our own uniquenesses.
But then, are labels still needed at all? A friend of mine commented
that ey thought the world would be better all round if people spent
less time banging on about What They Like To Do In Bed (or similar), and
more time just doing it.
Ey has a point. It prompted me to wonder why so many of these self-identification labels
do
revolve around What People Like To Do In Bed (bisexual, asexual, pansexual, panromantic, aromantic, polyamorous, monogamous,
sex-positive, kinky, vanilla, heteroromantic, gynesexual...). Why should
What One Likes To Do In Bed be of anyone else's concern apart from the
other person[s] in the bed?
The ones that don't
(genderqueer, transmasculine, butch, femme, neuro-atypical, cisgender,
feminist, neurotypical...) seem to have the broadly unifying
characteristic of describing What You Are Like. Presumably, if these labels describe What One Is Like, one spends most of one's time
being like that - so why should one need to wave around a label proclaiming that One Is Like That?
The answer I came up with:
Actually,
the sexuality labels don't just tell you what the person likes to do in
bed. They tell you how ey negotiates some of the most intense and
complex relationships someone can possibly have with [an]other human
being[s]. They tell you, through eir choice of label (
pansexual over
bisexual,
gyneromantic over
homoromantic), how ey views these other human
beings, on what levels ey chooses to interact with them, and how ey
responds to the ways eir sexuality is perceived in society at large.
In
short, they tell you an awful lot about the most intimate facets of the
person's character. In this way, they're just like the What You Are
Like labels. If someone chooses to identify as genderqueer, ey's making
clear the angle from which ey approaches interactions with other people,
the way in which ey responds to the pressures and perceptions of
society at large. If someone identifies (positively) as cisgender, ey's
sending a message to other people that ey recognises the diversity of
human experience and identity, and is willing to engage with them on a
deeper level than would, say,
Simon Hoggart.
It's
funny that these issues of (largely) gender and sexuality are,
essentially, the last great taboos - in that even in These Enlightened
Times
TM, the vocabulary to describe them is mushrooming year on year, as people finally find the courage to try and express
who they are. And, no, they shouldn't need to, it should be obvious from "what they're like". But it's
not.
If people don't stand up and wave their labels around, their true
personalities will be ignored, drowned out by the default white noise of
Everyone Is A Monogamous Heterosexual Man/Woman Who Behaves Exactly
Like This [In Bed].
Sure, it saves time and
effort. You're more than welcome to go with it. But personally, I prefer
my interactions with other human beings to be more intense, complex,
and rewarding - cos, y'know, people are
fascinating!